Posted 09 October 2008 - 11:35 PM
Since we are witnessing history in the making (and it is interesting to watch and learn), and the economics will affect Imminst to some degree, and this is the least politicized thread, I'll make some quick comments here.
- The stock downturn is a combination of irrational fear and complexities within the trading system. I am amazed at how much the fear/herd mentality still reigns in this era of more accessible and open information. As an example, CHK, a company I bought stock in, dropped down to its book value today. For traders, this is an amazing event. If the stock had gone any lower, someone with sufficient funds could have swooped in, bought 51%, sold the assets tomorrow (wells, buildings, contracts) and made a few hundred million dollars. As far as the complexities of the trading system goes, we have big mutual funds and hedge funds who have to sell stock even if they think it is a bad move because panicked investors want to get out. ETFs also drive stocks down irrationally. If the ETF goes down, it drags all stocks in the sector down, even the ones with billions of dollars cash on hand.
-Source of the problems: The housing market of course, but also all the financial instruments that were based on mortages and increasing house values. Big investment banks, mortage houses, even insurance companies, were leveraging their assets at 40:1. Most of them did not understand exactly how these CDSs, CDXs, Mortage backed securities worked or the risk involved. It all went poof.
- The government actions: idiotic at best. Elrond has already mentioned the problem with fiat money and inflation. The financial stimulus package back in June did not work. It just gave people money they did not earn, no value was created, it just postponed the financial downturn by a couple weeks. The 800 and some odd billion "rescue" package will not work either. The government plans to buy some of these "toxic" assets from banks for price not determined by the market - some people say 0.30 on the dollar. Ok, let's do some math. The banks were using one dollar worth of real assets (that real asset is now probably worth much less than the original dollar given events over the last couple of months and the continuing decline in housing prices) to create 40 dollars worth of speculative paper assets. So I am thinking the government might be paying (.30 X 40) 12 dollars for something that is worth less than 1 dollar or close zero by the time they get around to buying these things. Some of the assets have been marked down but inflation of the money supply works against the mark downs. There is no way the government will make money in this deal. As far as the housing help within the bill, they are only going to artificially prop up house values for many more years than should be and those houses are going to eventually fall apart. If they own any mortages (even partially), then the people who live in the houses will have no incentive to take care of the house - remember "the projects". Also, if a house price is being artificially propped up by the government no one is going to buy it. Who is going to buy a house for $300,000 when they know it is truly only worth $150,000. Prices need to fall. People who are paying $2000 and $3000 dollars a month mortage payments can afford to live in an apartment or trailer. I know it sounds harsh but that is what I did before I could truly afford a house.
- All of the Fed actions (plus the bailout, plus the stimulus, and god forbid another stimulus) are mortgaging our future away. In the last year the government (Fed included) has put us (Americans) on the hook for at least 2 trillion dollars and maybe more. It is an interesting mathematical analysis that the national debt is currently on an exponential trend toward infinity. Something bad will happen if this keeps up. It isn't at the level where I think the U.S. will default on t-bills, and I don't want to be accused of spreading fear, but the thought of default has popped into my head for the first time in my life.
-When the history is written I think we will see the folly of the government policy quite clearly (both parties share blame creating it and both collaborated in the folly). Easy credit, easy home loans, ballooning credit card limits, etc... got everyone into this mess and what did the government do - it handed out more money, printed more money, cut the interest rate EVEN more, took on more debt, etc... Instead of dealing with the short term pain and returning to sound fiscal policies, they just did more of what got us into trouble. Amazing.